Dedication of the Eloise Butler Memorial

1934 History
of the Eloise Butler Wildflower Garden

Winter 1933/1934

Martha Crone
Martha Crone in the Garden in 1951, photo - Martha Crone Collection, MHS.

1934 would be Martha Crone’s 2nd year in charge of the Garden, which now begins its 28th year.

What Garden Curator Martha Crone called “an unprecedented drought” in 1933, was to lead to much plant damage in the coming spring of 1934. Although that season was not as stressful as the later 1958-1959 winter it is likely that the lack of snow during the winter of 1933-’34 and unusually warm January temperatures causing a day-night freeze -thaw cycle, would be the prime causes of the plant loss only noticed in the spring. The snow depth in December and January rarely exceeded 4 inches and due to the well above average temperatures in January there was no snow cover in February and March 1934. Her position this year would continue be "temporary" curator. (1)

Spring 1934

Preliminary notes about the plants.Native Status: Some of the plants obtained by Eloise Butler in the early years of the Garden were not native to Minnesota or if native, may have been difficult to establish in the Garden. Most of these are no longer present. Martha Crone was somewhat more selective of native plant material, but also brought in many non-native species, and many of her imports have not survived either. The plants illustrated here, so one can see what they looked like, are mostly of the class no longer extant in the Garden. Some of those plants still existed at the time of Martha Crone's 1951 Garden Census and they are identified by the "(M.C.)" following the plant name. As for plants mentioned here that are still present in the Garden today, there may have been numerous re-plantings, and most have a web link to a detailed information/photo page, or, if not, are noted as being present in the Garden today - these are not illustrated in this article. Botanical classification: Over the years Botanists have reclassified many plants from the classifications in use at the time Eloise Butler wrote her Garden Log or when Martha Crone prepared her census. I have retained the nomenclature that Eloise Butler or Martha Crone used and then provided the more current classification as used by the major listings in use today, particularly Flora of North America, and the Annotated Checklist of the Vascular Flora of Minnesota.

Butler Memorial Tablet
The Eloise Butler Memorial Tablet, dedicated on May 4, 1934, (photo at top) which is mounted on a large boulder that sits in the open area in front of the Martha Crone Visitors Shelter.

Martha opened the Garden on April 1st with 2 inches of snow on the ground. Heavy rain on April 5th washed out the Garden paths and by the 8th the last ice melted in the bog pools. Snow Trillium bloomed on the 9th. The warmer weather of February and March was not to last into April. The month turned very cold. She reported that all plant growth was retarded due to extreme cold, with ice forming on the ponds each day. On the 21st water froze in the office and again on the 27th, with 1/2 inch of ice on the ponds. In spite of this the Bloodroots bloomed on the 24th. Then the weather abruptly changed. The next day the temperature reached 87 degrees followed by 90 degrees on the 29th.

Martha Crone reported that the unprecedented drought of 1933 had wiped out the entire supply of Showy Orchids, Shooting Star and some varieties of Ferns. She reported that other showy plants took their place.

Arrowleaf Violet
Arrow-leaf Violet (Viola sagittata). Photo ©Larry Allain @ USDA-NRCS PLANTS Database

On the 23rd of April a fire occurred on the west boundary where a small wooden building burned. Martha called for help and the damage within the garden itself was limited. Martha logged some replanting later in the season in the fire damaged area “Near the Mayapple” which is curiously close to the area of the “Pinetum” that was damaged by fire in 1910.

On May 4th a bronze tablet in honor of Eloise Butler was dedicated. Eloise had died the previous Spring. It is mounted on a large boulder that sits in front of the current Martha Crone Visitors Shelter. The cost of fabrication was paid by a group of Ms. Butler’s former pupils and her friends. Details on the tablet and dedication.

Prickly Pear
Prickly Pear (Opuntia humifusa) Photo ©Ted Bodner @ USDA-NRCS PLANTS Database

The heat wave continued in May. On the day of dedication of the tablet the Garden was very parched. Nationally, this was the dust bowl era. May in Minneapolis was the warmest in history, with a temperature of 106 degrees on May 31st and no rain, dust on everything. The ferns were drying to a crisp. Still, Martha reported that the birds were nesting and laying eggs and she was able to bring in new plants among which were a number of violets and Lady’s-slippers, especially the Small White Lady’s-slipper (Cypripedium candidum) of which she planted 41 from a source at Twin Lake.

Early Plantings not present today (see notes at top of page and immediately below):

Species Notes: Like Eloise Butler, Martha also kept a Garden Log of her planting and from this log we can note plants where the year 1934 is her first reference to them. Here is a listing of most of those first-listed plants. In first position are the common and botanical names that she used; these are followed by other common names for the same plant and the newer botanical classifications, if any. Plant sources are Minnesota sources and the plants are native to the State

snowberry
Common Snowberry (Symphoricarpos albus). Photo ©G D Beberau

Martha also planted species that are still represented in the Garden today, including:

Bloodroot, Jack-in-the-Pulpit, Snow Trillium, Wooly Blue Violet, White Trout-lily and Greater Yellow Lady’s-slipper and Arrow-leaf Violet; (Viola sagittata -now- Viola sagittata Aiton)

Summer 1934

Christmas Fern
Christmas Fern (Polystichum acrostichoides)

Martha Crone reported that the number of bird students visiting the Garden had greatly increased “due to the large number of birds that nest here attracted by the natural water supply and food and feeling free from molestation.” Dr. Thomas Roberts (author of Birds of Minnesota and for who the Roberts Bird Sanctuary is named), after he had conducted his bird class through the Garden presented to the Garden a set of colored bird plates for display on the walls of the Garden office (which Martha refers to as a “cabin”). These may have been reproductions of some of the plates used in his 2-volume book, originally published in 1932.

In August, Gertrude Cram was again vacationing on Isle Royal and sent a package of collected plants back to Martha at the Garden, including Fireweed. She writes:

"I found a clump of seedlings of Fireweed of which I dug some. Miss Butler said nothing would ever induce it to grow for her but I thought you might like to make another attempt. I am going to bring a few of the seedlings for my Garden. We'll see who has success, I have tried seeds and plants before and got nothing." (2).

Daily temperatures ran above average during the summer until late August, then there was a pronounced cooling. June 27th was another record breaker at 104 degrees and over July 21 to 23 there were three days above 104 degrees.

Fortunately for the Garden, rains occurred during the summer months and began to end what had been a multi-year period of dryness although Martha reported that the "drinking spring" dried up on July 2nd. This may have been the Great Medicine Spring outside the Garden where people came for water, or the Spring behind the Garden back gate, or possibly the spring on the Northwest corner of Glenwood and the Parkway.

Hay-scented Fern
Hay-scented Fern (Dennstaedtia punctilobula) Photo ©Emmet J. Judziewicz, Wisconsin Flora.

Early Plantings not present today (see notes at top of page and the “Species Notes” in the Spring section):

Walking Fern
Walking Fern (Asplenium rhizophyllum) Photo ©Thomas G. Barnes @ USDA-NRCS PLANTS Database

Martha was a great lover of ferns and in 1933 when she assumed the curator position she included ferns in her plantings. In 1934 she brought these in for the first time in her tenure (the first three are still extant):

Some of the plants Martha planted during the summer months are still in the Garden today in about the same places. These include:

Blue Jacket, Cardinal flower, Fireweed, Great St. Johnswort, Hepaticas, White Trillium,Queen of the Meadow, Greater Yellow Lady’s-slipper, Sweet Fern and Tamaracks (that she obtained from the quaking bog). Pale Corydalis, also planted, is no longer extant.

Azure Bluets
Azure Bluets (Houstonia caerulea) Photo ©Thomas G. Barnes @ USDA-NRCS PLANTS Database
Horsemint
Horsemint or Spotted Bee-balm (Monarda punctata) Photo ©G D Bebeau
Three-leaf goldthread
Three-leaf Goldthread (Coptis trifolia) Photo ©Kitty Kohout, Wisconsin Flora.

Autumn 1934

Lesser Purple Fringed Orchid
Lesser Purple Fringed Orchid (Platanthera psycodes). Photo ©G D Bebeau.

Early Plantings not present today (see notes at top of page and the “Species Notes” in the Spring section):

The Gentians were obtained In September, some from a source in Ramsey County and some from Turtle Lake. This plant she called “one of the wildest, as well as one of the most charming wildlings.” She was going to attempt to germinate seeds the following winter. (Ed. note: This plant has been very difficult to maintain in the Garden. It has been tried a number of times, all unsuccessful in the long run). Gentiana crinita became, in later years, an emblem of The Friends of The Wild Flower Garden when The Friends named their newsletter the Fringed Gentian™.

Some of the plants Martha planted during the fall months are still in the Garden today include:

Sky blue Aster, Smooth Blue Aster.

A large Polyporus fronds mushroom appeared on September 1st and she took it the state fair where it weight 9 lbs. (The following year a 25 pound' er would be produced at the same tree).

Garden Curator Martha Crone's planting of new plants in the Garden totaled 996 plants during 1934, of which, in October, were 36 small Kentucky Coffeetree (Gymnocladus canadensis), obtained from New Ulm. She heeled them in for transplanting the following spring. A number of these trees still are present in the Woodland Garden today. Note: 25 years earlier, Eloise Butler had also planted some Kentucky Coffeetree.

Final Report for the year:

Martha reported that the total plantings for the year comprised 97 species representing 67 genera and 39 families. Martha closed the Garden on Sunday September 30th amid beautiful weather and bright fall foliage.

Daily temperatures in October and November were above average, but with good precipitation through the end of the year. Snow depth in December averaged about 6 inches.

Fringed Gentian
Fringed Gentian (Gentiana crinita). Photo by Martha Crone, Sept. 25, 1950, courtesy Martha Crone Collection, MHS.
Lesser Fringed Gentian
Smaller Fringed Gentian (Gentianopsis virgata) Photo ©Hugh H. Iltis, Wisconsin Flora.

Note 1: Martha was appointed "temporary" curator in April 1933 to work until Oct. 1st, 1933 for $60 per month. (Letter of Superintendent Theodore Wirth to the Board of Park Commissioners dated April 18, 1933). This was confirmed in 1936 and 1938 by the Minneapolis Civil Service Commission that her position was "temporary curator" at the same rate of pay. It was not until April 4, 1940 that the position was confirmed permanent.

2: Letter from Gertrude Cram to Martha Crone posted from Isle Royal, August 1934, Martha Crone collection, Minnesota Historical Society.

Historical photo at top of page - dedication of the memorial tablet for Eloise Butler - Photo courtesy Martha Crone Collection, MHS.

Previous Year ----------- Subsequent Year

Links to related pages:
- Abbreviated Life of Eloise Butler
- Martha Crone - 2nd Garden Curator
- Ken Avery - 3rd Curator and Gardener
- Cary George - 4th Gardener
- Our Native Plant Reserve - Short document on the origins of the Garden.
- Eloise Butler's writings, a selection of essays written by Eloise Butler on the early Garden years.
- Geography of the Garden- an illustrated tour

References:

(1) Garden Log - Native Plant Reserve, Glenwood Park, Minneapolis, MN by Eloise Butler

(2) Martha Crone's Garden Log and her 1951 Census of plants in the Garden.

(3) Martha Crone's Annual Report to the Board of Park Commissioners dated Nov. 27, 1934.

(4) Various papers and correspondence of Eloise Butler in the collection of the Minnesota Historical Society.

Historical Climatology of Minneapolis-St. Paul Area by Charles Fisk.

Download Printable Version

Friends Home Page

©2017 Friends of the Wild Flower Garden, Inc. All photos are the property of The Friends unless otherwise credited. Photos credited to others are used with permission for educational purposes, for which The Friends thank them and the organization providing the photos. Text and research by Gary Bebeau. "http://www.friendsofthewildflowergarden.org" - 0201147